Tele Vue NP101 Review
I have an old 1960s
book about Mars with wonderful illustrations by Chesley Bonestell,
my favourite space artist. Unfortunately, it also has comedic text that makes
the 1960s sound more like the 1860s. For example, the author devotes an entire
chapter to the canals of Mars and their construction!
What relevance does
this have to Tele Vue’s premium four-inch refractor –
the NP101? The book in question derides Beer and Madler
(producers of the first Mars Map) for having used only a four-inch refractor, describing it as, “about the same
aperture as the coin telescopes set up in public parks”.
It turns out that
almost everything written in my charming old Mars book is wrong. Nowadays, we
know there are no canals on Mars and contrary to the author’s prejudices, a
four-inch apochromatic refractor can
show a surprising amount of planetary detail, if it’s a good one. Which is
where we get to Tele Vue’s NP101.
At
A Glance
|
Telescope |
Tele Vue NP101 |
|
Aperture |
101mm |
|
Focal
Length |
540mm |
|
Focal
Ratio |
F5.4 |
|
Length |
~650mm |
|
Weight |
~4.5 Kg |
Data from Tele Vue.
What’s
in the Box?
Design
and Build
The NP101 looks like most other Tele Vue telescopes, like a slightly bigger TV-85. Internally,
though, the NP101 is unlike smaller Tele Vues because
it is a (once unusual, but now less so) four-element optical design called a Petzval. The NP101 is an evolution of other fast,
flat-field Tele Vue four-inch refractors, like the
Genesis.
Optics
Like other Tele Vues, the NP101 objective lens sits in a slim cell and is
almost as wide as the tube. The curves on the glass are gentle – not what we
might expect with a fast lens; that’s because really
it’s an F11, not an F5.4 at all – I’ll explain why in a moment. As with all
modern Tele Vues, collimation is not adjustable: the
cell is held to the tube by three dome-headed bolts which are tightened at the
factory once the cell has been nudged into perfect alignment.
The NP101 is Tele Vue’s current premium four-inch using the Petzval design. The photo below shows the Petzval lens at the front of the NP101’s focuser. So what exactly is a Petzval
anyway?
A Petzval
combines a long focal length (in this case doublet) objective with a smaller
doublet field flattener/reducer in front of the focuser. The Petzval lens corrects many of the aberrations inherent in
the objective, along with halving the focal length and reducing the physical
length. So a Petzval is a
compact, highly-corrected, short focal-length four-element refractor.
However, the Petzval lens doesn’t correct for chromatic aberration
(false colour), just for other (monochromatic) aberrations, like off-axis
astigmatism and coma. The level of false colour is determined by the objective.
That’s why the original Petzval, the ‘Fluorite’
Genesis, was really a semi-APO: the fluorite was in the Petzval
lens, not in the objective which was an ordinary achromat. In the case of the NP101,
the objective is an ED glass doublet apochromat
of about F11, so correction for CA should be virtually perfect and it is.
Summary:
the NP101’s Petzval design gives a fast
focal ratio (F5.4) with a flat field and virtually no false colour, all
in a relatively short tube.
Petzval
lens, seen through the objective, at the front of the NP101’s focuser.
Tube
The NP101 looks very
much like Tele Vue’s other refractors, past and
present. The original NP101 was almost identical in appearance to the older
Genesis. So the tube is powder coated in a durable
pebble finish, whilst the sliding dew-shield and the focuser are in satin
black. You either love or loathe Tele Vue’s standard
metal screw-on lens cover; at least the NP101 version seems easier to thread
and less screechy than my old TV-76’s
The Petzval design makes the NP101 shorter than the (now
defunct) TV-102, but a little longer (at 64 cm, 25.5 inches) than its 540mm
focal length would suggest. Note: Tele Vue claim
airline portability for the NP101 in its short soft case, but for most airlines
22” is the maximum.
Weight, at just over
4kg, is very modest, though the ‘Imaging System’ version (see below) is a bit
heavier. The typical Tele Vue flocking material (it
looks like matt black sandpaper) in place of baffles makes the tube compact, at
a bare 4” diameter. The Petzval lens is well recessed
at the front of the focuser, so no risk of damaging it with a diagonal.
Tele Vue’s flocking material looks like sandpaper, but it works.
Focuser
The original rack and
pinion focuser has a cast body and the traditional TeleVue
“mag wheels”; a dual-speed pinion assembly is available for retrofit. The
latest version has a FeatherTouch dual-speed pinion
as standard. The oldest versions have a simple chrome focuser tube with a
single tension knob, whilst modern ones have a satin-finish CNC focuser of
greater precision, with two tensioners and two locking set-screws. The new
design is more stable with heavy loads and has less image shift when locking
it.
Original focuser with
single lock-screw.
Later (non-IS) focuser
with twin lock-screws.
NP101 or NP101is?
The ‘is’ stands for
‘Imaging System’. The two NP101s I have owned have been the standard visual
versions. These differ from the NP101is in two key areas
1)
The NP101is has a larger focuser with
features suited to CCD work: a larger draw-tube, a built-in micro-focuser and a
visual back with four set-screws for perfect centring and a plate that allows
small adjustments of tilt so you can get your camera perfectly aligned to the
optical axis.
2)
Perhaps more significantly, the imaging
system version has a larger Petzval lens to minimise
vignetting (loss of brightness at the field edge), which is otherwise a problem
with Petzvals.
If
you want to image with a full-frame chip, then you will need the i.s. version. For visual use, or smaller sensors, the
standard version will likely be just fine.
The imaging-system focuser
on an NP127.
Mounting
Like other smaller Tele Vues, the NP101
has a clamshell ring which is slim and attractive, but doesn’t hinge like usual
(you need an Allen key to remove it). The clamshell has two ¼-20 threads on the
base set at a standard spacing that fits Tele Vue’s
mounts. If you splash
out for Tele Vue’s own dovetail, the NP101 can be
quickly swapped between a Panoramic or Gibraltar and a Vixen or Sky-Watcher
mount, because the dovetail replicates the ¼-20 threads of the clamshell base,
so that you don’t have to remove it to swap.
The Gibraltar is the better of Tele Vue’s
mounts for the NP101, but the lighter Panoramic is workable, if a bit vibey.
Don’t try the NP101 on a Telepod!
The TV-Vixen dovetail replicates the TV ¼-20 threads of the
clamshell, so it goes straight on a Gibraltar head.
Accessories
The NP101 ‘package’
includes clamshell, a dielectric 2” diagonal and a 20mm Plossl
Eyepiece. A compact soft case, like the ones provided with the TV-76, is an
optional extra that makes the NP101 “just about” airline portable, as I’ve
said. Other accessories include finders, a reducer and (of course) a huge range
of eyepieces that are guaranteed to work with the NP101’s fast focal ratio.
Older NP101s have a
big hard case like the NP127s (shown above), but more recent ones have a more
compact version.
In
Use – Daytime
This is purely an
astronomical ‘scope, right? Wrong! The NP101 makes the finest terrestrial
‘scope I have ever used, albeit too large to take into the field. With a good
wide field eyepiece (a Pentax XW 20mm or Nagler 17mm
T4 come to mind), the NP101 gives views of birds and wildlife that have to be
seen to be believed. I recall a memorable morning watching a squirrel eating
nuts in a tree about 100m away, it was as if I was right there sitting on the
branch with him. The reason for this brilliant (literally) terrestrial
performance is the combination of high optical quality, perfectly flat and
coma-free field and complete absence of chromatic aberration. For all these
reasons, the NP101 also makes a superb telephoto lens for wildlife photography
as well (note the swirly bokeh, typical of Petzval
camera lenses).
Dusk snap of deer
through NP101.
My local Jackdaw
colony, silhouetted at dusk, usually cause false colour problems, but not with
the NP101.
In
Use – Astrophotography
This is not the
imaging-system version, but even so, put a DSLR in the back and the wide flat
field and fast f-ratio give superb results on bright DSOs. No flattener or
reducer is required – the NP101 already has one built in (though you can fit
another to give an even faster f-ratio). The arguments about whether built-in
or add-on reducers are better will continue, but if you’ve spent any time
messing with adapters trying to get a reducer to work right, you’ll appreciate
the hassle-free NP101.
If you want to image
the Moon or planets you really need a much longer focal length, but the NP101
still delivers sharp images of the Moon.
The following images
were taken at prime focus and are unprocessed, apart from cropping. As you can
see, the deep-sky image has pinpoint stars to the edge and good coverage on
APS-C, with just a little vignetting in the corners that the I.S. would
doubtless fix. Blue-bloating is modest.
In
Use – The Night Sky
General Observing Notes
Despite being an ED
doublet, the NP101 has minimal chromatic aberration due to the long native
focal length of the objective (it’s an F11, you will recall, which is much
longer than a 4” ED doublet needs to be for merely good correction).
Views are generally
very flat and well corrected, especially with eyepieces like Naglers and Ethos.
Cool-down
You might think that
having the airmass in the tube constrained between two lenses would be a
cool-down problem and the larger NP127 is
a little slow to cool, but with the NP101 cool-down is quick and benign (i.e.
largely free from transient pinching, astigmatism, spherical aberration etc).
Star-Test
Like most Tele Vues I have tried, the NP101 exhibits a little
under-correction, but is otherwise very good.
The Moon
With a focal length of
just 540mm it is true that you need barlows or fancy
eyepieces to achieve planetary and lunar powers, but the results are worth it.
Given the right seeing, the NP101 will happily take a 2.5mm Nagler
to give 216x, though usually the 3.5mm or 5mm are better choices. Given that
level of magnification, the NP101 is much like any other top-flight 4” APO on
the Moon – i.e. absolutely superb, with sharp, high-contrast views in stark
greys and whites – a fest’ of rilles, domes, subtle
rays and crater chains.
Jupiter
Most surprising, given
the astrograph-like spec’, is the planetary resolution on offer with the NP101.
My best views of Jupiter ever were with the NP101 from my balcony in superb
seeing at the very end of Summer.
My big ‘scopes were
out of action due to a mount problem and I nearly didn’t observe at all. It was
late and I was about to turn in, but decided to have a peek at Jupiter, so I
plonked the NP101 on the balcony and let it cool whilst I cleaned my teeth
ready for bed. Stepping up to the low power eyepiece, I immediately noticed
something was unusual. Jupiter, even at just 25x, was like an image from a
book. At higher powers, a wealth of belts and swirls and spots and festoons
were visible, along with the red spot, like a mini space-probe view.
Mars
When it comes to the
Red Planet, the polar caps and major albedo markings – Syrtis
Major, Mare Acidalium -are readily visible with the
NP101, refuting that ‘60s astronomer’s “coin telescope” comparison. Many
doublets are poorly corrected in the red, which can lead to problems when it
comes to Mars. But the NP101 gave sharp views, free of the softness and
stray-light that can beset other APOs on the Red Planet.
Deep Sky
Tele Vue’s products have always majored on the simple pleasure
of star-sweeping, so it goes without saying that the NP101 gives beautiful
views of clusters and bright nebulae. Again, it is that perfectly flat and very
wide (due to the short focal length) field that is the key here: diamonds on
black velvet, edge to edge, with superb contrast. Wide-field eyepieces do give
that “space-walk” feel that is a stated Tele Vue aim.
I really enjoyed
sweeping the Milky Way for clusters using a Nagler
17mm giving 32x magnification, but the NP101 will do small planetaries
and double stars at high power too – I split Rigel without trouble and the
Double Double was easy too.
Summary
The NP101 is quite
competitively priced in the USA – comparable to other premium 4” APOs; here it
is expensive, which is a shame.
Cost aside, it is very
hard to fault the NP101. Indeed, if someone were to put a gun to my head and
force me to own just a single telescope, this would be high on the list,
because it does everything. Not only does it perform well for visual or imaging
use on all types of target, astro’ and terrestrial,
it is compact and highly portable: light, quick to cool and easy to mount. The
icing on the cake is guaranteed quality and a huge range of Tele Vue accessories to go with it.
The other main
competitor Petzval – the Takahashi FSQ-106 – may be a
slightly better dedicated imaging scope, but it is also heavier, more expensive
and less suited to higher images scales and visual use. A Takahashi FC-100D (or
TSA-102, TMB 100-8 etc) might well be just a tiny fraction sharper on planets
at high power, but is typically less portable and lacks the wide, flat field
for star-sweeping and imaging.
So
is the NP101 the best do-everything small telescope currently available? I
think it just might be: highly recommended.